Think!

The What-the-Hell Effect – Why One Bad Decision Can Become Ten

You’ve eaten well all week, then someone brings cake into the office. You have a piece. Suddenly the internal conversation changes:

Well, I’ve ruined today anyway. Might as well get takeaway tonight and start again Monday.

The same thinking can appear with exercise, spending, drinking, screen time or almost any behaviour we are trying to control. The first slip may be relatively insignificant. Yet somehow, one bad decision can quickly become permission for several more.

Psychologists have a wonderfully technical term for this: the “what-the-hell effect”.

 

What the hell is the what-the-hell effect?

The concept emerged from research into restrained eating. Studies found that people deliberately restricting their food intake could sometimes eat more after consuming something they believed had broken their diet.

Rather than compensating for the indulgence, the thinking appeared to shift towards: the diet is already blown, so what the hell. Researchers Herman and Polivy described this as a temporary abandonment of the goal once a self-imposed boundary had been crossed.

The interesting part is that the initial behaviour has not necessarily caused much damage. One piece of cake has not undone a week of eating well. One missed workout has not eliminated months of exercise. One unnecessary purchase has not destroyed a savings plan. The bigger problem can be what we decide that lapse means.

 

When goals become all or nothing

Many of us turn continuous goals into binary ones.

Good or bad.
On the diet or off it.
Disciplined or undisciplined.
Success or failure.

As long as we remain on the “good” side of the boundary, the rule helps guide behaviour. But once we cross it, there can suddenly seem little reason to keep exercising restraint.

Through my own attempts to change habits and adopt ‘better behaviours’, I’ve generally come to believe that when it comes to food, exercise and everyday routines, moderation and balance are more sustainable than rigid rules. Part of the reason is that a flexible routine has room for real life. If having dessert, missing a gym session or enjoying a lazy evening is already allowed occasionally, none needs to represent failure.

A routine that can survive a bad day may ultimately be stronger than one that requires every day to be good.

 

A lapse doesn’t have to become a relapse

A similar idea appears in research on behaviour change and addiction through what is known as the abstinence violation effect.

The theory proposes that after a lapse, interpreting it as evidence of personal failure – I have no willpower; I always do this – can reduce confidence and make returning to the unwanted behaviour more likely.

Importantly, researchers emphasise that progressing from a lapse to a full relapse is not inevitable. How people respond to the lapse matters.

There’s an important distinction between:

“I made a poor choice.” and: “I’m hopeless at this.”

The first describes an event. The second turns it into an identity.

 

The “I’ll start again Monday” trap

The what-the-hell effect often comes with another familiar thought:

I’ll start again tomorrow.

Or perhaps Monday. Next month. After the holiday.

Starting fresh feels appealing because it gives us a clean psychological slate. Research by Janet Polivy and Peter Herman has explored how attempts at self-change can themselves create optimism and a renewed sense of control, even when our expectations about change are unrealistic. The danger is that tomorrow’s promised discipline can become permission for today’s excess.

Instead of waiting for the next perfect starting point, often the better opportunity is simply the next decision.

Had cake at morning tea? Lunch can still be healthy. Missed Monday’s workout? Wednesday is still available. Spent more than planned yesterday? You don’t have to abandon the budget for the month.

 

Progress rather than perfection

None of this means goals, rules or discipline are unhelpful. And there are clearly some behaviours where moderation may not be appropriate. But for many everyday habits, rigid perfection can create its own vulnerability. If success means never slipping up, eventually almost everyone fails.

Sustainable behaviour change may be less about avoiding every lapse and more about becoming better at recovering from one. Treat the lapse as a single event. Work out what triggered it. Adjust if necessary. Then return to the behaviour you wanted at the next opportunity. Because one bad decision rarely destroys a good habit but deciding that it does might.

 

 

Square Holes is a cultural insight studio.

We design mixed method explorations of people and culture beyond the category,  uncovering the patterns, tensions and shifts shaping behaviour to inform strategy, inspire innovation and enable confident decisions. Our studio model brings together the right mix of thinkers, researchers and specialists for each exploration. If you’re navigating change, entering a new market, or seeking deeper understanding of people and culture, let’s start a conversation >

Share this: